Hopes for Shenzhen: China & Russia As Champions of the Global Majority

Though sometimes dismissed as a mere photo-op, the upcoming meeting in Shenzhen between Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin, and Donald Trump represents a hopeful triumph for the global majority.

Think about what that signifies. It means that the world’s principal imperial power and the leader of white-world colonialists is finally meeting as a co-equal with heads of the two major members of the global majority organization called BRICS+ [Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa plus (so far) Egypt, Ethiopia, Indonesia, Iran, Saudi Arabia, and the United Arab Emirates.].

It’s one of the most hopeful developments in global politics that I’ve witnessed over my 86 years on this planet.

My optimism is inspired by the sea change such meeting represents – transition from past colonial exploitation, and present forever wars, to a possible future characterized by dialog, diplomacy, and reparations for all that colonial and neo-colonial exploitation.

Colonial Exploitation

For more than 500 years, Europe and European settlers have built up vast fortunes and have created “developed world” ways of life by invading and conquering by force, divide-and-rule strategies, and the establishment of obedient local monarchs. That’s what colonialism is.

It’s a system of plunder whereby “civilized” armies invade weaker “uncivilized” territories to steal their goods and govern them by force of arms often taking the form of outright genocide (as happened in what eventually became the United States of America). Often, it’s all been justified on religious grounds – to save the souls of the “natives.”

Typically, the colonized countries are balkanized by imposition of arbitrary borders drawn up by colonizers grossly ignorant of the impositions’ effects separating extended families, allied tribes, and cultural sites such as temples, and community burial grounds. In Exterminate All The Brutes, Raoul Peck summarizes the dynamic in three words: civilization, colonialization, and extermination.

In China, the exploitation in question took the form of events that unfolded during that civilizational state’s “Century of Humiliation.” The most disgraceful events during those hundred years were the two Opium Wars waged by Great Britain against China (1839-1842 and 1856-1860). Till those wars, China had been the world’s most productive rival of the British Empire. China was largely self-sufficient without need of British products. As described by Enrique Dussel, it had long since anticipated the great achievements of Europe’s Industrial Revolution – including printing press, paper money, the steam engine and steel production. The forced import of English opium changed all that reducing China to comparative passivity, dependency, and yes, humiliation.

Following the triumph of its revolution in 1949 Chinese leaders beginning with Mao Zedong realized that such disgrace was made possible by their country’s military weakness. They resolved never again to replicate such debility.

For its part, Russia’s association with the colonized Global Majority came much later.

More than ever, it incurred the wrath of the collective west by the success of its October Revolution in 1917. That groundbreaking workers’ rebellion introduced into Eurasia at a national level a country and its satellites that refused to conform to the standard capitalist system of exploitation. Though constantly accused by the west of merely exchanging one form of colonialism for another, it successfully endured invasions by European and American colonialists along with subsequent continuous threats and an extended Cold War to protect the undeniable gains of its revolution that with unprecedented speed transformed Russia from what Marxist economist Richard Wolff calls Eurasia’s most backward country in a world superpower.

All of that changed in the early 1990s when a series of socio-economic reforms by Russian president Mikhail Gorbachev introduced reforms mirroring the values of his western adversaries. He termed them glasnost (openness) and perestroika (restructuring).

Such changes opened the door to the unexpected deterioration of the Soviet system.

Very quickly Russian anti-communists cooperating with the anti-Russian collective west saw their opening to finally end any alternative to their system of control. Overwhelming western funding and propaganda inserted themselves into the electoral process that followed on the heels of Gorbachev’s reforms. This led to the replacement of the president himself with a more-malleable head of state, Boris Yeltsin.

Yeltsin oversaw what his virulently anti-communist successor Vladimir Putin called “the greatest geopolitical catastrophe of the 20th century.” He was evidently referring to the sale of Russian national assets at fire-sale prices to western investors and local oligarchs. He was referring to the eruption of widespread poverty – the consequence of lost employment following on the “restructuring” of Russia’s economy, to the disappearance of socialist programs including the disappearance of pensioners’ income. According to Putin, Yeltsin’s reforms impoverished ordinary people and enriched foreign investors and their local allies in ways completely reminiscent of IMF “structural adjustments” imposed on the west’s former colonies. In this way, Russia was reduced to Third World status.

Putin himself was seen by the west as a worthy successor of Boris Yeltsin when he succeeded the latter in the year 2000. However, in his famous Munich Speech of 2007, Putin shocked his western supporters by a kind of declaration of independence. He decried the unipolar system that he described as the root of the world’s problems. He denounced the rise of oligarchical classes and declared his intention to redirect his presidency accordingly. He also expressed concerns over NATO’s expansion and advocated for a multipolar global structure.

As far as the collective west was concerned, Putin’s election and that Munich speech marked a break in Russia’s reform trajectory. It identified Russia’s president as an enemy to be vilified and as an object of regime change efforts.

The point here is that under Yeltsin, Russia was reduced to Third World status. It became the victim of IMF structural adjustment policies. However, by playing a leading role in the formation of BRICS Putin transformed Russia into a powerful leader and champion of the Global Majority.

War vs. BRICS

All of that, in summary goes a long way towards explaining the current wars in Ukraine and Iran. Arguably, both are really wars against BRICS – against the united Global Majority. Both can be seen as wars to reassert the unipolar authority of the United States along with the subservient, impoverished, and dependent status of the Global Majority. The wars represent steps to the dethronement of Russia and China as champions of the former colonies. Or, as expressed by Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin, United States goals in Ukraine were to weaken Russia and to remove Vladimir Putin from office. According to Secretary of State Marco Rubio Ukraine is a proxy war between the United States and Russia.

Facing up to such realities is no doubt difficult for most Americans to accept. After all, isn’t the United States a benefactor of the former colonies? Isn’t a major point of its foreign policy to alleviate poverty and spread democracy throughout the world?

Apparently not, if we are to believe the words of President Trump. He sees not only the “developing world” united in BRICS as inimical, but in addition any country that does trade with them. 

And this anti-poor position is not peculiar to Donald Trump. In 1949, it was recommended as official U.S. policy by George Kennan, the author of the U.S. policy of containing the Soviet Union during the Cold War. Kennan wrote: “We have about 50 percent of the world’s wealth, but only 6.3 percent of its population, In this situation, we cannot fail to be the object of envy and resentment. Our real task in the coming period is to devise a pattern of relationships which will permit us to maintain this position of disparity without positive detriment to our national security. To do so we will have to dispense with all sentimentality and daydreaming and our attention will have to be concentrated everywhere on our immediate national objectives. We need not deceive ourselves that we can afford today the luxury of altruism and world benefaction. We should cease to talk about vague and unreal objectives such as human rights, the raising of living standards and democratization. The day is not far off when are going to have to deal in straight power concepts. The less we are hampered by idealistic slogans, the better.”

According to Kennan, a very key player in the formation of U.S. policy, the purpose of it all is to maintain (not alleviate) the extreme wealth-disparity between the United States and the rest of the world. The United States is not about making life better for others or about acting unselfishly. Rather, human rights, democratization, and improving the living standards of other nations are considered ill-defined and even unreal. Such considerations are not to be factored into decision-making. Mouthing slogans to the contrary may be fine, but their content must be ignored in favor of unadulterated power relationships – i.e. in favor of forcing others to conform. As President Trump has put it, the only acceptable slogan is “America first.”

In contrast to such convictions, the unabashed stated point of BRICS is to foster respect for human rights, democratization, and improving the living standards of all. This makes the leaders of BRICS, Russia and China, as well as BRICS members such as Iran, enemies of the unipolar state.

The contrast also lends added color and deeper importance to the upcoming Shenzhen meeting.

Hopes for Shenzhen

As I indicated at the beginning, it might be a grave mistake to consider the coming Shenzhen meeting as a mere photo op for heads of state concerned about advancing their own self-interests and those of their nations similarly seeking world dominance. While such concerns are self-admittedly true for the North American participant, the considerations I’ve just shared indicate something else for the Russian and Chinese presidents.

All indications are that besides seeking what’s best for their own countries, Presidents Xi and Putin are internationalists whose national experience enables them to identify with the Global South and the exploitation that the former colonies have experienced over the last 500 years.   

While it might be true that nothing substantial is likely to occur at Shenzhen, simply understanding the meeting as an encounter of equals – between the exploited and their principal exploiter – is more than enough to justify its success even before the principals shake hands. The meeting puts many things into perspective including borders, immigration, reparations, and internationalism itself. It also helps transcend narrow Overton windows concerning Putin, Xi and the wars in Ukraine and Iran.

In the perspective just shared, the two Global South leaders potentially emerge as statesmen representing the interests of the world’s historically oppressed. Their policies as embodied in BRICS and in China’s Belt and Road Initiative become understandable as departures from the cruel orientations of “diplomats” like George Kennan. The installation of high-speed rail across the planet and the construction of ports, bridges, highways and dams can be seen as extremely generous acts of what the U.S. once called “foreign aid.” 

Moreover, considered in this way, Shenzhen reminds all concerned that borders are not sacred; they change all the time, and colonizers not only drew them (often haphazardly) to satisfy their larcenous interests, but even once drawn, their authors assumed permission to cross and violate their demarcations with abandon.

This puts into salvific perspective the immigration of the colonized into the countries of their exploiters. Turn-about is fair play. And whether they realize it or not, immigrants from the Global South are peacefully voting with their feet to exact reparations for the crimes of would-be civilizers who wantonly colonized and cruelly exterminated the inhabitants of the lands they ravaged. The “invasions” of immigrants across the “developed world” call into question the legitimacy of all the planet’s borders.  

None of these profound realizations is likely to register in the presses of the colonial powers.

But keep them in mind as events in Shenzhen unfold. Their day will come.

The New “Matthew 25” Christian Politicians

Readings for 33rd Sunday in Ordinary Time: Proverbs 31:10-13, 19-20, 30-31; Psalm 128:1-2, 3, 4-5; 1 Thessalonians 5:1-6; Matthew 25:14-30.

A recent New York Times article brings some welcome news. Progressive Democrats are finally discovering that Jesus has something to say about politics. And what he says has more to do with feeding hungry people and welcoming immigrants than with the religious right’s familiar obsessions.

The article describes a new crop of politicians who, like Senator Raphael Warnock, call themselves “Matthew 25 Christians.” They take their cue from Jesus’ identification with the hungry, thirsty, naked, sick, imprisoned and unwelcome. They connect those words with health care, immigration and our responsibility to care for one another. Good for them. It’s about time someone challenged the Republican Party’s claim to own Christianity. (See what Presbyterian seminarian and senator elect from Texas, James Talarico, says about this in the video above.)

However, the article also shows how easily Jesus’ teaching can lose its bite. It describes the final section of Matthew 25 as “softer and more soaring” than what precedes it. And it presents today’s gospel selection, the Parable of the Talents, as a lesson about making good use of our money and abilities. The writer even jokes that it teaches compound interest.

Apparently, Jesus wants us to make a killing in the market and then remember the poor. That interpretation should please J.D. Vance and his billionaire benefactor, Peter Thiel. But I doubt it would please Jesus. And Pope Leo XIV has been saying things that make that comfortable arrangement harder to defend.

To see why, let’s look again at today’s familiar parable. It’s about economics—about investment, profit-taking and a boss who expects other people to make him richer. It’s also about a servant who refuses to cooperate and suffers the predictable consequences.

Usually, we’re told that the boss represents God. The successful servants represent people who develop their God-given gifts. And the servant who buries his money represents the rest of us when we fail to live up to our potential. We should work harder, take some risks and stop wasting our talents.

But there’s another way to hear the story. Listen to it from the position of the people doing the work rather than the man collecting the profits. Then notice what the third servant says about his employer: he harvests where he hasn’t planted and gathers where he hasn’t scattered. In plain English, the boss lives off other people’s labor. He’s a hard-ass who expects his underlings to make him money while he’s away.

The first two servants go along. They double what he gives them, and he rewards them handsomely. They’re successful because they accept the arrangement and do what it takes to keep it going. The third servant refuses. He buries the money, gives it back and tells his boss to his face what kind of man he is.

Naturally, the boss throws him out. He also takes the servant’s money and gives it to the man who already has the most. Those who have get more. Those with little lose even that. We hardly need a Bible commentary to recognize that arrangement. We live with it every day.

Now, I realize this isn’t the interpretation most of us heard in Sunday school. But why should we automatically identify this particular rich man with God? Jesus told stories about unjust judges and dishonest managers too. We don’t have to turn every powerful character in his parables into God. Especially when the character admits that he expects to collect where others have done the planting.

Read this way, the third servant is the story’s troublemaker. He refuses to help the rich get richer. Worse still, he says aloud how the system works. Like Jesus and John the Baptist, he discovers that telling the truth about powerful people can cost you dearly.

And that brings us back to the Times article and its Matthew 25 Christians. The chapter’s concluding scene has Jesus judging people by what they’ve done for those at the bottom. But shouldn’t that lead us to ask how so many people got there? Who took their land? Who kept their wages low? Who made their health care unaffordable? Who benefited while they lost their homes?

Otherwise, we end up praising the successful servants for enriching the master and then congratulating ourselves for feeding some of the people his system leaves hungry. Surely Jesus is asking more of us than that.

Pope Leo seems to think so. In Dilexi Te, the document begun by Francis and completed and issued by Leo, the pope insists that Christians confront the causes of poverty. He repeats the condemnation of the “dictatorship of an economy that kills.” He refuses to leave human well-being at the mercy of markets and financial speculation. The poor need justice now. They cannot eat promises that prosperity will eventually trickle down.

That teaching creates problems for a Christianity tied to billionaire power. Consider Vance’s relationship with Peter Thiel. Vance worked for Thiel’s investment firm. Thiel later put $15 million into a super PAC supporting Vance’s Senate campaign. He also helped shape Vance’s religious thinking. That’s quite a combination: the boss, the political benefactor and an influence on the convert’s Christianity.

Thiel, for his part, once wrote, “I no longer believe that freedom and democracy are compatible.” Think about that. Ordinary people might use democracy to raise wages, tax fortunes or stop corporations from doing whatever they please. Apparently, that creates a problem for freedom—at least freedom as understood by a man with billions to protect.

Leo approaches things differently. In his encyclical on artificial intelligence, Magnifica Humanitas, he asks what happens to the people whose work makes the new technology possible and whose livelihoods it may destroy. He calls for worker protections, participation and rules governing the changes. Investors don’t get to decide everything simply because they own the machinery.

That sounds like a reasonable application of Matthew 25. Before celebrating another technological fortune, ask who did the work and who will pay the price. Before praising the harvest, find out what happened to the people who planted it.

House Speaker Mike Johnson has found another way around the chapter’s demands. Asked about Leo’s appeal to Matthew 25 on behalf of immigrants, Johnson said the obligation to welcome strangers applies to individuals rather than civil authorities. Apparently, Jesus can tell us how to treat the immigrant next door, but he has nothing to say about what we authorize our government to do to that same person that he specifically identifies with. We shouldn’t mistreat Jesus, but governments can.

How convenient. We can offer a family groceries with one hand and support policies that tear it apart with the other. We can call the first act Christian charity and the second responsible government. Somehow, Jesus is supposed to approve of both.

But Matthew’s judgment scene begins by gathering “all the nations” before the Son of Man. That doesn’t give us a detailed immigration bill. It does make it hard to imagine that governments have been excused from treating people humanely. Where does Jesus say that kindness stops being obligatory when we enter public office?

And where does the Times get the idea that this is the chapter’s softer part? Jesus identifies himself with people we would rather ignore and makes our treatment of them the measure of our lives. Religious credentials don’t get us off the hook. Neither do patriotic speeches or claims that we were simply enforcing the law.

The new Matthew 25 Democrats should take that seriously too. I’m glad they’re talking about Jesus. But the test will come when feeding the hungry requires confronting the people who profit from keeping wages low. It will come when providing health care means challenging those making fortunes from sickness. It will come when their wealthy donors discover that these Christians mean what they say.

That’s when they’ll need the courage of the third servant. He doesn’t give a speech about compassion while continuing to enrich his boss. He refuses to cooperate. He tells the truth and accepts the cost.

The master calls that failure and throws him into the darkness. The wider gospel gives us reason to question the master’s verdict. Jesus himself was rejected by the powerful. And he promised God’s kingdom to people the powerful had pushed aside.

So yes, let’s welcome the return of Matthew 25 to our political conversation. But let’s hear the whole challenge. Feed hungry people, welcome strangers and care for the sick. Then ask why so many of our neighbors need rescuing in the first place—and why the people who benefit from their suffering keep getting richer.

Jesus wasn’t blessing the billionaires. It’s time his would-be followers stopped doing it for him.

Wisdom Is A Woman: Patriarchal Billionaires Like Peter Thiel Aren’t Listening.

Readings for 32nd Sunday in Ordinary Time: Wisdom 6:12-16; Psalm 63:2, 3-4, 5-6, 7-8; 1 Thessalonians 4:13-18; Matthew 25:1-13

Last Tuesday’s resounding Democratic victory over Trumpism has given us reason to hope. It suggests that Americans can recognize the connection between their daily struggles and a government that serves the wealthy while encouraging everyone else to blame immigrants, racial minorities, and one another. People struggling to pay for groceries, housing, and medical care have begun directing their anger upward. For those accustomed to ruling through division, that is dangerous.

The election hardly means that Democrats have become champions of liberation. Far from it! Too many remain beholden to the same donors, military interests, and corporate priorities as their Republican counterparts. However, voters have opened a door. The question now is whether those elected will walk through it —or once again squander this opportunity by prioritizing the interests of their wealthy sponsors.

Biblical Wisdom

That is where this Sunday’s readings enter the picture. Their theme is wisdom: the ability to recognize what is happening, receive instruction from unexpected sources, and make provision for the work ahead. And the first thing they tell us is that Wisdom is a woman. In a world whose most powerful men seem increasingly certain that their wealth entitles them to govern the rest of us, that deserves our attention.

Consider Peter Thiel. According to Christopher Hale’s account of a secretly recorded October 19 lecture, the billionaire concluded his Nashville series on the Antichrist by calling the city “arguably the global capital of Protestantism.” He urged his listeners to involve themselves in finance, technology, politics, and the battle of ideas. His final instruction was blunt: “get over your inferiority complex and fight.”

Fight whom? Read alongside Thiel’s attacks on Pope Leo XIV and his advocacy of safeguards for artificial intelligence, the appeal suggests a struggle over Christianity itself. Nashville’s Protestant constituency becomes a potential counterweight to Rome’s insistence that technological power must answer to human dignity. A billionaire whose interests are affected by public oversight is recruiting believers for a battle over the moral legitimacy of that oversight.

Theology Centralized

I never expected theology to become quite so openly relevant to our political struggles. Yet Thiel seems to understand something many Christians have forgotten: what we believe about God affects what we permit powerful people to do. A Christianity centered on private salvation can leave economic arrangements largely undisturbed. A Christianity that takes seriously Jesus’ good news to the poor eventually asks who owns everything, who makes the decisions, and who pays for the mistakes.

That second Christianity is troublesome for billionaires. It refuses to assume that the ability to develop a technology confers the right to impose its consequences on everyone else. It asks workers about displacement, parents about their children, and communities about surveillance and computerized warfare. From a liberation theology perspective, Leo’s demand for accountability belongs here. Those exposed to technological power deserve a voice in governing it.

Feminine Wisdom

Now listen to the alternative offered in today’s first reading. Wisdom comes looking for us. She waits at the gate, travels the roads, and meets those willing to receive her. She does not require an invitation to a closed-door lecture or admission to an exclusive circle. But she does require something that great wealth can make difficult: the willingness to be taught.

Her femininity matters. For centuries, churches have overwhelmingly pictured divine authority as male while restricting women’s authority to interpret it. Yet here Scripture places a woman before us as the embodiment of the understanding we need. She is active, searching, and persistent. Our task is to become receptive to her. That means surrendering the assumption that we already know because we hold the office, possess the money, or occupy the pulpit.

Liberation theology makes this receptivity concrete. It begins by listening to people whose experience prevailing arrangements teach us to dismiss. Ask a mother facing eviction whether the economy is working. Ask an immigrant harvesting our food what freedom means. Ask a Palestinian parent what our politicians mean by security. Ask a survivor of sexual exploitation how institutions protect their reputations while leaving children unprotected.

The poor and oppressed do not know everything. They do know things that their employers, landlords, generals, and benefactors can afford to ignore. That is the basis of their hermeneutical privilege—their particular ability to help us understand what is happening. The view from beneath the system exposes features that remain invisible from the boardroom. Wisdom requires allowing that testimony to change our minds and our policies.

Americans Not Hopelessly Divided

This is also why I question the endless insistence that Americans are hopelessly divided. Our disagreements are real, sometimes bitter. Nevertheless, most of us need the same basic things: affordable homes, adequate food, medical care, meaningful work, and a future for our children. There is also ground for solidarity in opposition to war, the destruction of Palestinians, sexual exploitation, and corruption. An election cannot prove agreement on all those questions. It can reveal an opening for bringing people together around them.

Divide-and-conquer politics works by concealing those possibilities. The immigrant becomes the explanation for low wages. The poor family becomes the explanation for public debt. Meanwhile, fortunes accumulate, weapons contracts multiply, and the people making the decisions present themselves as our protectors. Wisdom asks us to examine that diversion. Who benefits when the underpaid worker blames another underpaid worker?

The Epstein scandal gives this question a particularly ugly form. What I call the “Epstein Establishment” is the culture of access, deference, and protection surrounding people whose influence makes others reluctant to ask obvious questions. Association alone does not establish criminal guilt. But neither money nor political usefulness should shield anyone from investigation. Survivors deserve protection, the public deserves lawful disclosure, and credible evidence must be followed wherever it leads. The demand applies as firmly to church leaders as to financiers and presidents.

Here, too, wisdom is receptive. She listens to people whom institutions have trained themselves to disbelieve. She asks why a child’s account encounters so many obstacles while an influential man’s denial travels so easily. A church that preaches the social gospel must submit itself to that same scrutiny. Otherwise, its denunciations of worldly power become another exercise in protecting its own.

But today’s Gospel warns that recognizing injustice and welcoming an electoral victory are insufficient. Ten young women await a bridegroom. Five bring enough oil for a prolonged delay; five do not. All ten fall asleep. The wise women are as tired as the foolish ones. What distinguishes them is that they have made provision for a night longer than they expected.

That detail seems especially appropriate after Tuesday. Defeating Trumpism at the polls does not dismantle the interests that sustained it. They still possess money, institutions, media access, and the patience to wait for public enthusiasm to fade. Thiel’s appeal to fight should remind us that those interests are organizing. They intend to shape what comes next.

Our lamps need oil for that long night: organized communities, political education, independent sources of information, and habits of holding our own representatives accountable. We need people prepared to insist on affordable housing after the victory speeches end, to oppose war when their party supports it, and to defend immigrants when doing so becomes inconvenient. Those capacities develop through practice. They cannot be borrowed at midnight.

The psalm brings us back to thirst. Our souls thirst for God like dry earth thirsting for water. That image keeps spirituality close to the body and the land. People need actual water, actual bread, actual shelter. A religious language that turns those needs into mere metaphors allows us to feel spiritually nourished while our neighbors go hungry. The God for whom we thirst meets us in their demand to live.

Finally, Paul speaks to people grieving their dead. He assures them that those who have died will not be forgotten or left behind. For anyone struggling for liberation, that hope matters. The dead of war, exploitation, and preventable poverty are more than yesterday’s statistics. Their lives continue to make a claim on us. No election can bring them back, but the world we build can honor them or repeat the arrangements that killed them.

Conclusion

So let us welcome Tuesday’s victory and insist on what it makes possible. Let us listen before the consultants explain away the voters’ anger and the donors narrow the agenda. Wisdom is already at the gate. She may arrive as a woman whose testimony powerful men would rather dismiss, a worker they would rather replace, or a grieving parent they would rather keep off television. We will show that we have received her when their experience begins to govern our decisions. Until then, billionaires like Thiel will keep their hands on the switches—and call the arrangement Christian.

Democrats Have Won. Now Make the Powerful Answer

Tuesday’s historic Democratic victories have opened the possibility of holding powerful people accountable and making government answer to ordinary Americans. Democrats must seize that opportunity. Their new congressional majorities must produce something more than changes in committee leadership, congratulatory speeches, and preparations for the next election.

They should begin with an issue whose moral stakes require little explanation: the sexual exploitation of children and the possibility that wealth and political power have protected those responsible. People may find arguments about monetary policy or congressional procedure difficult to follow. They understand child abuse. They understand the difference between investigating an accusation and concealing the evidence needed to investigate it.

That makes the Epstein files a defining test of the new Democratic majority. Will Democrats pursue the evidence wherever it leads, including toward people within their own political and financial circles? Will they protect survivors while exposing powerful adults? Or will accountability once again stop where influence begins?

The same question runs through the broader program Bernie Sanders has urged Democrats to embrace: Whom does government serve? Drawing on his proposals together with priorities of my own, here is the agenda I believe Democrats should pursue.

  1. Release the Epstein files and begin serious hearings. Demand immediate disclosure of all records required by law. Committees should begin available investigative work now and prepare hearings backed by subpoena power as soon as the new majority takes office. Require preservation of records, obtain missing documents, and investigate any unlawful withholding, destruction of evidence, or intimidation of witnesses. The House Judiciary Democrats’ October 26 staff report provides a concrete starting point. It assembles accounts involving eleven women, including five who accuse Trump of rape or sexual assault in Epstein’s company or presence, and calls for an independent investigation. These are allegations and committee findings requiring examination, rather than judicial determinations of guilt. Congress should follow the report’s documentary references, question relevant witnesses, and establish what investigators pursued, abandoned, or withheld. The circulating video attributed to a woman identifying herself as Dr. Larissa Portnoff also warrants careful follow-up. In it, she alleges abuse beginning around age eight, continuing through approximately twelve, and renewed targeting at sixteen or seventeen. The reporting located about the recording acknowledges that its authenticity had not been independently confirmed. Investigators should establish its origin, seek her testimony with appropriate protections, and examine any corroborating evidence and allegations of intimidation. Due process must govern the investigation, and accusations must be tested against evidence. That is precisely why full lawful disclosure and serious hearings are necessary. Neither presidential office nor party affiliation should place anyone beyond investigation.
  2. Establish Medicare for All. Make comprehensive health care a right available to everyone. While pursuing universal coverage, protect Medicaid, lower prescription drug costs, and prevent people from losing access to treatment. No one should have to choose between medicine and groceries or remain in an abusive workplace to retain insurance. Medical care should follow human need.
  3. Make public higher education tuition-free. Open state universities, community colleges, and public vocational programs to qualified students without imposing decades of debt. Address existing student debt and the living expenses that keep poorer students from completing their education. An educated population is a public good, and preparing young people for useful, fulfilling lives is a public responsibility.
  4. Raise the federal minimum wage to $20 an hour and empower unions. Establish a clear timetable and automatic adjustments for rising living costs. Make union organizing easier, strengthen penalties for retaliation, and help workers secure first contracts. Add paid sick leave, paid family leave, and protections for workers excluded from effective labor safeguards. People who create society’s wealth deserve both a fair share and a meaningful voice.
  5. Tax concentrated wealth and strengthen Social Security. Enact a carefully designed wealth tax on billionaires, close tax shelters, and enforce tax laws against wealthy evaders. Remove the ceiling on earnings subject to Social Security payroll taxes. Guarantee retirees a monthly income floor of at least $1,200, protect higher existing benefits, and adjust that floor for inflation. A lifetime of work should lead to security.
  6. Make housing affordable. Build and rehabilitate public and nonprofit housing, expand rental assistance, protect tenants against displacement, and help first-time buyers. Confront speculative practices that treat entire neighborhoods as cash cows. A government capable of mobilizing enormous resources for military purposes can mobilize resources to keep its people housed.
  7. Act on climate change. Commit the country to the Paris Agreement’s goals and adopt enforceable measures consistent with them. Invest in renewable energy, public transportation, efficient buildings, and a reliable electrical grid. Guarantee good jobs and transition assistance for affected workers. Communities with the fewest resources should receive protection first, while the greatest financial obligations fall on those most responsible and most able to pay.
  8. Put artificial intelligence under democratic control. Impose a moratorium on new AI data centers until enforceable safeguards address electricity costs, water consumption, environmental harm, privacy, and employment. Bernie Sanders and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez have already proposed legislation establishing such a pause. Stop the development of artificial superintelligence and develop a public utility framework for essential AI infrastructure. Decisions capable of transforming human livelihoods must answer to democratic institutions.
  9. Provide a workable path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants. Recognize immigrants’ labor, family relationships, and contributions to community life. Protect asylum, due process, and workplace rights. Hold exploitative employers accountable. We cannot honestly celebrate the people who harvest our food, build our homes, and care for our relatives while treating those same people as disposable.
  10. End unauthorized wars and reduce excessive military spending. Reassert Congress’s authority over war and appropriations. Pursue diplomacy and negotiated settlements, scrutinize weapons programs, and demand credible accounting from the Pentagon and its contractors. Redirect substantial savings toward water systems, bridges, schools, housing, and climate resilience. Provide transition investment for workers and communities dependent on military production.
  11. End American support for Israel’s destruction of Palestinian life. Stop funding and arming Israel’s genocidal assault on Palestinians. Suspend assistance to the Israeli government until it ends the abuses and withdraws from illegal settlements in accordance with international law. Support humanitarian relief, reconstruction, accountability, and Palestinian self-determination.
  12. Protect democracy against manipulation and purchased influence. Establish fair redistricting standards, strengthen voting rights, expand ballot access, require disclosure of political spending, and pursue public campaign financing. Oppose partisan gerrymandering even where it benefits Democrats. Representatives should face meaningful electoral competition, and citizens should have political influence independent of their wealth.
  13. Defend reproductive freedom and equal citizenship. Protect abortion, contraception, and reproductive health care. Defend LGBTQ people against discrimination and uphold religious liberty for believers and nonbelievers alike. Resist Christian nationalism’s effort to turn a particular religious interpretation into everyone else’s legal obligation. Government must protect the equal standing of people with different convictions and identities.

Conclusion

This program will encounter formidable obstacles. Trump remains president, retains veto power, and can block legislation unless Congress assembles the votes to override him. Democrats must explain those limits honestly while exercising their own powers over investigations, appropriations, legislative debate, and public accountability. Their new majorities take office in January; preparation should begin immediately.

The party should publish a legislative timetable, hold substantive hearings, and make every member’s votes readily understandable. Seek agreements that improve people’s lives. Where proposals are blocked, identify who blocked them and whose interests that decision serves. Keep organizing after the vote.

The Epstein investigation belongs at the center of this effort because it asks whether powerful adults can escape scrutiny when children have been harmed. The economic program asks whether those same structures of privilege will continue to determine who receives health care, education, housing, and security. Each requires a government willing to confront concentrated power.

From the perspective of liberation theology, the measure of this new majority is the experience of those with the least protection: abused children, frightened witnesses, poorly paid workers, displaced families, and people living beneath bombardment.

Democrats have won the opportunity to act. Those people must now become the measure of what victory means.

Before You Vote, Remember: God Sides with the Immigrant

Readings for the 30th Sunday in Ordinary Time: Exodus 22:20-26; Psalm 18:2-3, 3-4, 47, 51; 1 Thessalonians 1:5c-10; Matthew 22:34-40

Before we cast our ballots in the coming midterm elections, we should ask a question that rarely appears in campaign advertising: Whose cries does God hear? This Sunday’s liturgy of the word answers that question.

Today’s first reading supplies an answer so direct that politicians who campaign on their Christianity might prefer we skip it. It says that God hears the immigrant, the widow, the orphan, and the poor neighbor whose necessities someone else has taken away. The passage warns those with power that their treatment of these vulnerable people matters enormously to God.

That makes today’s readings (please take the time to click their links) an uncomfortable guide to the approaching election. The political right has made immigration a dependable instrument of fear.

Americans worried about housing, wages, medical bills, and their children’s futures are encouraged to direct their anger toward people with comparatively little power over those conditions. Apparently, the people who pick our vegetables, clean our hotel rooms, repair our roofs, and care for our elderly parents have somehow acquired the ability to ruin the richest country in the world.

Pew estimated that fourteen million undocumented immigrants lived in the United States in 2023. Whatever the precise number today, they remain a small minority in a nation of more than 340 million. Are we seriously supposed to believe that workers who may be afraid to report an abusive employer are responsible for the insecurity afflicting the rest of us? That accusation deserves scrutiny every time a candidate repeats it.

Today’s first reading gives Christians a different starting point: “You shall not molest or oppress an alien, for you were once aliens yourselves in the land of Egypt.” The command makes memory a moral obligation. Remember what it means to be vulnerable. Remember what happens when a powerful society values outsiders’ labor while despising the people performing it. Let that memory shape how you exercise power—including the power of your vote.

When I began teaching at Berea College, I was surprised that colleagues who (for all their admirable qualities as scholars) were not friends of liberation theology, nevertheless recognized one of its foundational biblical insights: Israel’s fundamental understanding of its God came through the Exodus, not Genesis — i.e., through the story of deliverance of slaves from Egyptian bondage. Here was a God first encountered in the cries of exploited people and in the struggle to free them. Today’s reading asks the formerly enslaved to build a society that refuses to reproduce the arrangements of Egypt.

That is a serious challenge for an election campaign. Candidates invite us to imagine the country they would build. Christians must ask what place immigrants will occupy in it. Will they receive fair treatment and protection from exploitation? Will their children live in fear? Will their vulnerability become an opportunity for employers, political operatives, and others who benefit when people cannot safely defend themselves?

We also need to ask how people became migrants in the first place. Campaign speeches commonly begin the immigration story when a poor person approaches our border. An honest account would begin much earlier—when our corporations crossed theirs.

Consider Mexico. Under NAFTA and related economic reforms, U.S. agricultural exports gained expanded access to Mexican markets. Corn, soybeans, and other commodities moved south. Large producers and trading companies gained business. Small farmers faced competition within a system whose advantages were distributed very unevenly.

Research connects the expansion of agricultural imports and other rural economic changes with the displacement of workers who subsequently sought livelihoods in Mexican cities, border factories, and the United States. Trade was one factor among several others (including U.S. authored regime and climate change throughout the Global South), but it belongs in the immigration story.

For a farming family, losing a livelihood can mean losing the possibility of remaining where generations have lived. Young people leave. Families separate. Local businesses lose customers. Communities struggle to sustain the customs, relationships, and knowledge built around working the land. What appears in a corporate report as a market opportunity can appear in a village as the disappearance of its future.

Then comes the moral reversal that election rhetoric so often conceals. When a corporation crosses a border seeking greater profits, its movement is celebrated as enterprise. When a displaced worker crosses a border seeking a livelihood, the movement becomes a threat. The investor’s ambition deserves protection; the worker’s ambition becomes grounds for suspicion. We defend the freedom to sell the corn while condemning the movement of people whose livelihoods the new arrangements helped undermine.

Before voting, we should ask candidates to explain that double standard. Why should capital enjoy broad freedom to seek favorable conditions while workers must accept whatever conditions capital leaves behind? Why does “free enterprise” so often require freedom for investors and enforced immobility for people struggling to survive?

Those questions also expose the dishonesty of claiming that poor immigrants uniquely threaten local cultures. Fact is, economic power can destroy cultures much more thoroughly. Outside interests can undermine a community’s livelihood, take control of its resources, and subordinate its needs to distant profits. A village emptied of its young people has suffered cultural disruption long before any of those young people reaches our border.

Americans have particular reason to approach the language of “invasion” with humility. European settlement and the expansion of the United States involved the brutal dispossession of peoples already living here. Native nations endured forced removal, massacres, and campaigns against their cultures. That history includes acts of genocide. Descendants of the settler society should hesitate before treating a migrant family’s search for work as an unprecedented assault on an innocent national history.

Exodus calls us to remember honestly. Our own history should deepen our obligations toward vulnerable newcomers. It should make us suspicious when politicians manufacture national innocence by placing national guilt upon impoverished outsiders.

The lending instructions in today’s reading make the same demand in economic terms. If a poor neighbor gives a cloak as security for a loan, the lender must return it before sunset. “What else has he to sleep in?” Scripture asks. In other words, the borrower’s need places a limit on the creditor’s power. A recognized financial claim cannot justify leaving a human being exposed to the cold.

That principle belongs in our voting decisions. A policy may be legal and still be cruel. An enforcement program may have funding and still inflict unjustifiable suffering. A contract may be valid and still exploit desperation. Christians must examine what these arrangements do to actual people, especially those least able to protect themselves.

In the Gospel, Jesus joins love of God with love of neighbor and says that the whole law and the prophets depend on them. Today’s first reading gives that love its concrete content. It concerns the immigrant’s safety, the worker’s wages, the borrower’s debt, and the child’s security. We cannot profess love of God while supporting the deliberate humiliation of people God commands us to protect.

Paul describes conversion as turning from idols to serve the living God. An election season offers plenty of idols: national greatness, wealth, party loyalty, the supposedly indispensable leader. Each becomes dangerous when its claims override our responsibility toward other human beings. Christian conversion requires the freedom to judge our preferred party by the Gospel, even when that judgment costs us something.

No party escapes that scrutiny. Democrats must answer for their immigration policies and their participation in economic arrangements that contribute to displacement. Republicans must answer for making vulnerable immigrants targets of collective blame and presenting harshness as evidence of leadership. Calling a policy Christian cannot exempt it from the commandment to love.

Before voting, then, ask concrete questions. Does this candidate protect workers or make them easier to exploit? Does this proposal provide fair procedures or encourage indiscriminate punishment? Does it address the causes of displacement? Does it help communities receiving newcomers obtain the resources they need? Does it recognize immigrant families as human beings whose security matters as much as ours?

Our ballots are one way we authorize the use of power over other people’s lives. Today’s readings ask us to exercise that authority with the immigrant, the widow, the orphan, and the indebted neighbor clearly in view. Their cries must reach us before campaign slogans drown them out.

Before you vote, remember whom God hears. Remember the history that brought us here. Remember the workers whose labor sustains our daily lives. And remember that the commandment to love our neighbor remains binding when we enter the voting booth.

Paulo Freire: The Friend Who Taught Us to See Differently

On our eighth wedding anniversary, Peggy and I had dinner in São Paulo with Paulo Freire and his wife, Elza. Afterward, one of the world’s great educators read aloud from Peggy’s unfinished doctoral dissertation on Freire himself. At one point, he encountered a lengthy quotation from his own work. He paused and exclaimed in English, “Right now, I am loving these words.”

I still remember that moment. There was something wonderfully unguarded about it: a thinker rediscovering his own thought through the work of a student who had become his friend. For me, it captures something essential about Paulo. Learning remained an encounter, even when the words being encountered were his own.

That memory returned recently when a friend, an editor at OpEdNews, asked about our relationship with Freire. He had just seen Reading the World, the new documentary directed by Catherine Murphy and Iris de Oliveira. Knowing that Peggy and I had a long history with its subject, he wanted to hear more.

Our story began before Peggy and I knew each other. Separately, we had read Pedagogy of the Oppressed. It helped shape us as students and eventually as teachers. Looking back, I would say that Paulo entered our marriage before we ever met him.

His book’s brilliant title suggested two meanings to me. First, it concerned an education through which oppressed people could acquire literacy and participate more fully in public life. In Brazil, where literacy was a condition of voting, teaching people to read could change the electorate. At Angicos in 1963, approximately 300 people became literate through 40 hours of instruction spread over several weeks. Education was opening a political door previously closed to them.

The title’s second meaning was even more challenging: the oppressed themselves have something indispensable to teach the rest of us. People who endure hunger, exploitation, exclusion, and humiliation know things about society that comfortable people can spend their lives avoiding. Their experience raises questions that respectable institutions often discourage. Why are some hungry while others accumulate fortunes? Who benefits from the arrangements we are taught to consider natural?

Education begins to become revolutionary when those questions enter the classroom. For Peggy and me, that meant reconsidering our authority as teachers. Students arrived with knowledge acquired through their families, work, struggles, and communities. Our responsibility included helping them examine that knowledge—and allowing it to challenge our own.

When we married in 1976, we were both working at Berea College. Over the ensuing years, our reading and teaching included Neil Postman and Charles Weingartner’s Teaching as a Subversive Activity, Howard Zinn’s A People’s History of the United States, James W. Loewen’s Lies My Teacher Told Me, and books recovering Black history and women’s history. Frances Moore Lappé and Joseph Collins’s Food First further challenged our assumptions about hunger and poverty.

Freire supplied a thread connecting those works. Each invited us to examine the world from perspectives pushed to its margins. Each questioned the innocence of conventional education.

Then, in 1982, we attended a weeklong seminar led by Freire at Boston University. At the time, Peggy was pursuing her doctorate in philosophy of education at the University of Kentucky. Her dissertation explored Paulo Freire and moral imagination: our capacity to envision human possibilities beyond the arrangements we have inherited. She approached Paulo and asked whether she might study with him at his center in São Paulo. He warmly encouraged her.

That invitation changed our lives. During my first sabbatical at Berea and still studying Portuguese, we went to Brazil in 1984. Peggy’s dissertation was already well underway. She studied at Freire’s center and worked directly with literacy teams in the city’s favelas. There, the questions raised by his books belonged to people’s daily lives. Words emerged from experience. Learning to read involved examining the conditions under which people worked, raised children, found shelter, and struggled to survive.

Meanwhile, I enrolled in a liberation theology seminar that placed Freire’s methods at the center of biblical reflection. I found myself sitting at the feet of theologians I had been studying for years. They helped me understand how “Base Christian Communities” used Freire’s methods in “biblical circles” to consider their efforts to follow Jesus. Their reading connected Scripture with high rents, inadequate water, starvation wages, and government repression.

Those connections transformed the questions brought to the Bible. What did Exodus mean to people seeking freedom? What did Jesus’ good news to the poor require in a neighborhood where families could barely eat? How might faith help people organize to change their circumstances? The poor were becoming interpreters of a tradition too often explained to them by others.

In 1984, Brazil was still under military rule. Freire had already experienced the consequences of awakening such questioning. After the 1964 coup, he had been imprisoned for 70 days. The authorities understood that people learning to name their circumstances might also begin to change them.

During our stay, Peggy and I came to know Paulo and Elza personally. That friendship gave a human face to ideas that had already transformed our work. Our anniversary evening remains its clearest expression. Paulo’s willingness to read Peggy’s developing dissertation aloud conveyed attention, encouragement, and intellectual generosity. The renowned educator took a student’s work seriously enough to enter into it with her. Her dissertation later received national recognition from the American Educational Research Association (AERA). But that evening offered a recognition of its own.

Our friendship continued after we returned to the United States. More than once, we attended workshops with Paulo and Myles Horton at the Highlander Folk School in New Market, Tennessee. We also became friends with Freirean scholars Henry Giroux and Peter McLaren, who helped us publish two books after Paulo’s death in 1997. The relationships continued the learning.

Today, when I think about Paulo Freire, I return to a question that has followed me through decades of teaching, writing, and theological reflection: whose experience helps us see what we have been missing? For Peggy and me, his answer led toward the poor and oppressed—and toward classrooms where teachers could also learn.

I remember the great thinker at his apartment, reading Peggy’s pages and delighting in words that still had the power to surprise him. That openness was part of his greatness. He helped us understand that a teacher’s work begins again whenever another person helps us see differently.

When A President Speaks Like God

Readings for the 26th Sunday in Ordinary Time: Ezekiel 18:25-28; Psalm 25:4-5, 6-7, 8-9; Philippians 2:1-11; Matthew 21:28-32.

Last Tuesday, before the United Nations, President Trump said he had “a big decision to make.” Would there be a deal allowing Iran to rebuild? Or would he “annihilate the Islamic Republic” and drive its people “into hell with no chance of survival”? Those are his words, as recorded in the available transcript of the speech. They sound like a man who thinks he’s God.

In any case, I keep coming back to the people who would have to live under such threat: a mother trying to get her children to school, a nurse caring for the sick, an elderly man who has already lived through too many wars. What decision have they made that gives an American president authority over their future? How can anyone speak of leaving a people without hope for future generations and call it a choice that belongs to him?

The United Nations was created so that nations would settle their conflicts without threatening one another with destruction. Its charter forbids members to use threat or unauthorized force against other states. Yet there stood the president of the United States, before that very assembly, speaking of annihilation in his illegal war of aggression.

This Sunday’s readings give us a way to judge what we heard.

Through Ezekiel, God asks a question: “Is it my way that is unfair, or rather, are not your ways unfair?” It is a question worth putting to every government that speaks of security while treating other people’s lives as expendable. Would we accept such words from the leader of another nation directed at us? Would we call them statesmanship if our own grandchildren lived under the threatened bombs?

Ezekiel does more than condemn wrongdoing. He says that people can turn from it. The one who has done evil can begin to do what is right and just—and live. The word turn matters. God does not demand that we defend yesterday’s course simply because we chose it yesterday. God calls us to change course when we see where it leads.

That is a word for our president and for everyone helping to prosecute this war. It is also a word for us. Americans can turn. We can refuse to lend our silence to threats made in our name. We can insist that diplomacy, the protection of civilians, and an end to the killing are possible and necessary. Ezekiel will not let us say that it is too late to do what is right.

Then Paul asks us to have the mind of Christ Jesus. In one of the most beautiful passages in the New Testament, he says that Jesus, though in the form of God, did not treat equality with God as something to be grasped. Instead, he emptied himself, took the form of a slave, and accepted death on a cross.

Think of the direction of that movement. Jesus goes toward those with the least power. He shares their vulnerability. He ends among the people an empire could execute.

Christ refused to grasp at godlike power. Our president appears eager to exercise it.

For Christians, that contrast should be impossible to miss. No human being has the right to decide that another people will have no future. And no follower of the crucified Jesus should be comfortable hearing such power claimed on our behalf. We cannot kneel before a man executed by an empire and then applaud an empire’s threat to destroy others.

Paul’s words are addressed to a community. He asks the Philippians to look not only to their own interests but also to those of others. For us, that means asking what the war looks like from beneath the bombs and from inside Iranian homes. It means seeing the people who will suffer before we repeat a government’s account of its aims.

We need not approve of Iran’s rulers to do that. We need not overlook injustice committed by any government. Iranian civilians do not lose their claim on our conscience because of what their leaders may have done. Their lives cannot be reduced to a bargaining chip in a dispute between states.

That brings us to Jesus’ story of the two sons. Their father asks each of them to work in the vineyard. One says no but later changes his mind and goes. The other says yes, sir, and never appears. Jesus asks which one did the father’s will. Everyone knows the answer.

He tells this story to the chief priests and elders. They know how to give the proper religious answer. But when John calls them to change their ways, they refuse. Meanwhile, people they look down upon—tax collectors and prostitutes—hear the call and respond.

It is hard to read that Gospel this week without thinking about the churches. We know how to say yes to Jesus. We praise the Prince of Peace. We recite Paul’s hymn about his self-emptying. Some Christian leaders have spoken against this war and pleaded for diplomacy; Pope Leo has done so. But after a threat as stark as the one voiced at the UN, why don’t we hear church leaders speak with unmistakable clarity about the lives at stake?

And I have to ask the same of myself. It is easy for me to preach against a president. The Gospel asks what I will do once I have finished speaking. Will I make my opposition known to those who represent me? Will I stand alongside people organizing for peace? Will I keep paying attention to Iranian lives when the speech has passed from the headlines? Jesus asks whether we actually go into the vineyard.

Perhaps some of us have supported the war. Perhaps some have feared speaking against it. Perhaps many of us have simply grown weary and stopped listening. The first son gives us reason for hope. His first answer was no. It was not his final answer. He changed his mind and went.

That possibility is the mercy running through all today’s readings. In the psalm we pray, “Teach me your paths.” Ezekiel says that we can turn and live. Paul shows us the path of Christ, who gave up power and stood with the vulnerable. Jesus tells us that what matters is whether we will take that path today.

I pray that our president will turn from the language of annihilation. I pray that our churches will find their voices. And I pray that we, who say yes to Christ every Sunday, will hear the invitation he places before us now: go into the vineyard. Defend the lives being threatened. Work for peace. RESIST. VOTE.

Eva, Willie, Neil, and the Music I Couldn’t Hear

Last night my granddaughter Eva took me to hear Willie Nelson and Neil Young in Bridgeport. That sentence still amazes me.

She is eighteen; I am eighty-six. At her father’s family birthday party two nights earlier, she had surprised me by asking, through him, whether I would go with her. I don’t know why she asked that way. We had recently returned from a trip to Chicago to look at the University of Chicago and Northwestern, and our time together had ended with a silence I couldn’t quite explain. Her invitation touched me deeply. She still wanted her Baba beside her.

On the way to the concert, it was like old times. Eva gave me a short, fascinating lecture on the Roman poet Lucan and his fraught relationship with Nero. Her grasp of Latin, classical history, and mythology already surpasses that of any student I taught during my forty years at Berea. She even surprised her high school Latin teachers by translating Martin Luther King Jr.’s “Beyond Vietnam” speech, delivered at New York’s Riverside Church, into Ciceronian Latin. I encouraged her to somehow publish her work. To call Eva an excellent student is a huge understatement. What delights me most is that she still likes sharing what she learns with me.

We have been going places and talking together for years. Once, in Granada, we went to hear Bob Dylan. More recently, Eva chose to spend part of our Chicago trip with my siblings. When she was fifteen, she gave a school speech about our friendship that moved me almost beyond words. She spoke of our walks, our conversations about economics and religion, and the fact that I had always taken her opinions seriously. Now, riding to Bridgeport, I had the pleasure of listening to her teach me.

The evening began with a video of Willie singing while images passed across the screen: Black and brown people, immigrants, people without homes. I couldn’t make out the song, but I could see whom we were being invited to notice. Before Willie appeared, those faces had claimed a place at his concert. For me, that was a kind of opening prayer.

Willie is ninety-three now and looks his age. At times he seemed to recite the words more than sing them. Still, what words they were. “On the Road Again” sounded different coming from a man who has been on that road so long. “Always on My Mind” carried its familiar regret. And near the end came “Last Leaf,” a song whose title alone had a particular force for an old man listening beside his granddaughter.

Neil Young joined Willie for “Are There Any More Real Cowboys?” Eva noticed something else I might have missed: Willie’s sons were there with him. She found it beautiful to see a father making music with his children. I did too, especially while sitting next to a grandchild who had brought me.

Willie’s set closed with religious music, including “I Thought About You, Lord,” “Will the Circle Be Unbroken?” and “I’ll Fly Away.” Eva leaned toward me and asked, “Why do they have to introduce religion here?”

“This is country music,” I shouted over the sound. “It’s a tradition.”

That was all I could manage over the music, though her question stayed with me. Eva has her own thoughtful relationship to religion. She considers herself an atheist and, years after I baptized her as a baby, even “unbaptized” herself. We have talked about such things all her life. Her question at the concert felt like another moment in that continuing conversation.

Had it been quieter, I might have said that people sing about an unbroken circle and flying away because they know that families part and lives end. The songs give voice to a longing many of us share, whatever language we use for it. Perhaps Eva would have told me more about what she heard in them. That is one of the pleasures of being with her: a question is seldom the end of a conversation.

We hadn’t realized how cold an outdoor concert would be. Eva was dressed for a very different evening. Several times I offered her my padded vest; once I even started taking it off. She firmly refused. Between sets, she bought a Willie Nelson hoodie. It pleased me that she found her own solution, though I kept an eye on whether she was warm enough.

Neil, at eighty, still has much of that unmistakable voice. I could recognize “Old Man,” “Heart of Gold,” “Harvest Moon,” and “After the Gold Rush,” even when I couldn’t follow every word. I felt the frustration of knowing these songs and losing parts of them to the volume and my hearing. For someone who has spent his life listening, teaching, and arguing over words, that loss is hard to ignore.

Then the crowd called Neil back. His first encore was “Living With War”; his second was “Rockin’ in the Free World.” That final song went on and on, loud enough that I briefly wondered what it had done to my ears. Yet somewhere in those ten minutes I forgot the cold. Afterward I turned to Eva and said, “Isn’t rock ’n’ roll great? I forgot I was cold.”

Young’s encore also sent my thoughts back to the faces in Willie’s opening video. A song about freedom ought to make us ask who gets to enjoy it, and who is left out in the cold. That question has guided much of my theology. It was there, too, among the amps and guitars.

But the deepest meaning of the night was simpler. On the drive there, Eva had brought Lucan and Nero into the car with us. At the concert, we noticed a father singing with his sons, talked as best we could over the music, and tried to keep warm. At the end, we let Neil’s guitar carry us along with everyone else.

I hope we have many more walks, conversations, and songs ahead of us. Last night gave me this much: Eva was beside me, Willie’s family was singing, Neil’s guitar was ringing through the cold, and for a while we listened together.

Seventy-Seven Times—and the Debts Americans Refuse to Forgive

Readings for 24th Sunday in Ordinary Time: Sirach 27:30—28:7; Psalm 103:1-2, 3-4, 9-10, 11-12; Romans 14:7-9; Matthew 18:21-35.

Americans live in a society obsessed with debt—and strangely selective about forgiveness.

When banks gamble recklessly and threaten the economy, governments rescue them. When corporations fail, bankruptcy courts allow them to reorganize and begin again. When wealthy investors lose money, tax laws often permit them to deduct those losses from future income.

But when poor people cannot pay medical bills, student loans, rent, or credit-card debt accumulated simply to survive, forgiveness suddenly becomes morally objectionable. Then we hear about personal responsibility. Then every dollar must be repaid. Then mercy will supposedly encourage laziness.

The same double standard operates internationally. Wealthy nations accumulate enormous debts and continue functioning. Poor countries are forced by international lenders to cut food subsidies, healthcare, education, and public employment to satisfy creditors whose loans have often enriched local elites and foreign corporations rather than ordinary people.

We readily forgive from the top down. We become merciless when forgiveness might benefit those at the bottom.

That is precisely the contradiction exposed in this morning’s Gospel.

Peter asks Jesus how often he must forgive someone who sins against him. Seven times? Peter probably thinks he is being extraordinarily generous. But Jesus answers, “Not seven times but seventy-seven times.”

In biblical language, that does not mean keeping a notebook until offense number seventy-eight. It means refusing to make vengeance a way of life. It means breaking the cycle in which injury produces retaliation, retaliation creates another injury, and violence continues from generation to generation.

To explain, Jesus tells a story about debt.

A servant owes a king “a huge amount.” The original Greek is more dramatic: ten thousand talents. A single talent represented roughly fifteen or twenty years of a laborer’s wages. Ten thousand talents, therefore, was not merely a large personal loan. It was an unimaginable sum—more than a worker could repay in thousands of lifetimes.

In other words, this is not simply a story about hurt feelings. It is about an economic system capable of creating impossible indebtedness.

The king orders the servant sold, along with his wife, his children, and all his possessions. That single sentence reveals the violence hidden beneath respectable financial arrangements. Debt has become a claim not only upon the servant’s labor, but upon his body, his family, and his entire future.

The servant falls to his knees and begs for time. Instead, the king does something astonishing: he cancels the entire debt.

That is Jubilee.

According to Israel’s ancient ideal, debts were to be periodically forgiven, enslaved debtors released, and land returned to families who had lost it. The purpose was to prevent wealth from accumulating permanently in a few hands while everyone else sank into hereditary poverty.

Jesus stands within that Jubilee tradition. At the beginning of his public life, he announces good news to the poor, release to captives, and liberation for the oppressed. In the prayer he teaches his disciples, “forgive us our debts” is inseparable from “as we forgive our debtors.”

The servant in today’s parable has been offered a new life. But he has not undergone conversion.

Leaving the king’s presence, he encounters a fellow servant who owes him one hundred denarii—a real debt, but tiny compared with the ten thousand talents just canceled. He grabs the man by the throat and demands payment. The second servant repeats almost word for word the plea the first servant had made: “Be patient with me, and I will pay you back.”

But the forgiven servant refuses. He has received mercy without learning mercy. He has escaped the machinery of oppression, yet immediately uses that same machinery against someone weaker than himself.

That is the central sin in this story.

The problem is not merely personal ingratitude. It is the refusal to extend downward the liberation received from above.

That makes this parable especially relevant to Christians in the United States. Our country has received advantages that cannot honestly be attributed to virtue alone: fertile land taken from Indigenous peoples, labor extracted from enslaved Africans, resources drawn from colonized countries, and a privileged position within the global financial system.

Yet instead of recognizing our enormous inherited debt, we often seize poorer nations by the throat and demand, “Pay what you owe.” We impose sanctions, collect interest, confiscate resources, and punish entire populations for resisting an international order designed largely without them.

The same pattern appears within our country. People whose families benefited from subsidized mortgages, inexpensive education, union wages, Social Security, and public investment may oppose similar assistance for younger workers, immigrants, or the poor. Like the servant in the parable, we forget what has been forgiven, subsidized, or simply handed to us.

But here we must make an essential distinction. Christian forgiveness does not mean that privileged observers may forgive crimes committed against other people.

I cannot forgive the slaughtered child’s killer on behalf of the child’s parents. Settler societies cannot absolve themselves of crimes against Indigenous peoples. White people cannot declare slavery and segregation forgiven without the participation of their victims. Governments responsible for war, torture, ethnic cleansing, or genocide cannot invoke reconciliation while the killing continues.

Only victims can forgive the injuries done to them.

Nor does forgiveness eliminate the need for truth, accountability, restitution, or protection of the vulnerable. There can be no genuine reconciliation without truth. Stolen land and wealth may require restitution. Those who remain dangerous may need confinement—not for revenge, but for rehabilitation and the protection of others.

Forgiveness is not forgetting. It is not pretending that evil did not happen. It is not allowing abusers to continue abusing. And it is never a command to the oppressed to accept oppression more politely.

Instead, forgiveness means refusing to become what has wounded us. It means relinquishing vengeance without relinquishing justice. It seeks restoration rather than humiliation, conversion rather than annihilation, and a future not permanently imprisoned by the past.

That is why Sirach asks, “Could anyone nourish anger against another and expect healing from the Lord?” Notice the word healing. Forgiveness is not presented primarily as obedience to an arbitrary rule. It is a form of healing. Hatred binds the injured person to the offender. Vengeance allows the perpetrator to continue occupying the victim’s heart and imagination.

Paul adds another dimension: “None of us lives for oneself.” That is the direct opposite of the individualism our culture teaches. We are not isolated competitors whose debts and injuries concern only ourselves. We belong to one another. Our lives are entangled. The suffering of immigrants, Palestinians, prisoners, impoverished workers, and sanctioned populations is not somebody else’s problem.

If none of us lives for oneself, then none of us is saved alone.

The Gospel’s final image of the unforgiving servant handed over to torturers is disturbing. It should not be used to portray God as an eternal torturer. The parable is showing what a world without mercy becomes. When we organize society around unpayable debts, resentment, punishment, and revenge, we build our own torture chambers—and eventually everyone lives inside them.

Jesus offers another possibility: receive mercy, practice mercy, and reorganize life around mercy. That means personal forgiveness, certainly. Families and communities cannot survive if every injury is preserved forever as ammunition.

But it also means social forgiveness: canceling predatory debts, ending sanctions that punish civilians, releasing those unjustly imprisoned, repairing the damage of racism and colonialism, and replacing retributive systems with restorative justice.

The test of whether we have understood God’s mercy is not how beautifully we praise it in church. The test comes when we meet someone who owes us—or someone our society has placed beneath us.

Will we seize that person by the throat? Or will we remember how much we ourselves have received?

“The Lord is kind and merciful, slow to anger, and rich in compassion.” A church that sings those words must become what it sings: a community that tells the truth, repairs what has been broken, defends victims, cancels impossible debts, and refuses to surrender the future to vengeance. That is forgiveness from the heart.

And that is what God’s Kingdom looks like when it enters history.