Readings for 24th Sunday in Ordinary Time: SIR 27: 30-28:7; PS 102: 1-4, 9-12; ROM 14: 7-9; JN 13:34; MT 18: 21-35
Today’s gospel is a confusing one. For me, it’s troubling. In fact, I’d go so far as to say that it illustrates what’s wrong with religion.
What’s wrong is that too often religion is made to justify violence, guilt, fear and economic exploitation. Its God is like a Mafia Don who intimidates, punishes, tortures, and never forgives. For the sake of money (!), He even engages in child trafficking and leg-breaking extortion.
That’s ironic, isn’t it? I mean, the gospel reading begins with Jesus’ comforting and challenging logion about forgiveness. How often should we forgive, he is asked? Jesus’ answer: “Always! In fact, you can’t put a number on it. But, if you insist, how about 490 times – 70 X 7?”
Jesus would surely say something like that. Seven times is not enough. Seventy times seven is more like it. That formula probably represents an authentic saying of the Master whose followers eventually saw as divine. His teaching: always forgive; that’s God’s way.
But then comes the confusing illustration that seems to contradict those comforting and challenging words. Matthew presents Jesus as identifying the God whom the Master embodied with a cruel king. The ruler’s actions contradict not only Jesus’ teaching about forgiveness, but everything the rest of today’s liturgy of the word says about Jesus’ compassionate God.
Think about it. In the first reading, Sirach says that anger and vengeance are hateful. Don’t cherish wrath or refuse mercy, we are told. Instead overlook the faults of others and heal, rather than punish.
In that respect be like God, the Responsorial Psalm tells us. God is always kind, merciful, slow to anger, and rich in compassion. The Divine One heals rather than punishes. In fact, in God’s eyes, we are for all practical purposes guiltless. He doesn’t even see our sins. As the psalmist puts it, the gap between us and guilt is infinite – as wide as that between east and west. That’s the way we should see each other too – entirely guiltless.
The alleluia verse continues in the same vein. It reminds us of Jesus’s words: “Love one another as I have loved you.” That means, as Paul says in the reading from Romans, living and dying as Jesus did – with a prayer of forgiveness for his executioners on his lips: “Father forgive them. They don’t know what they’re doing.” Jesus pardoned even his assassins and executioners.
But then comes that troubling illustration. Matthew presents Jesus as identifying his Father with a money lender – with a king whose first impulse towards his debtor is to sell him and his entire family – including his children – into slavery. That’s human trafficking. That’s trafficking in children.
Put otherwise, for the sake of recovering his money (!), no cruelty seems excessive. That’s evidently why the money lender employs torturers on retainer. Their job, as we see in the parable’s conclusion, is to squeeze blood from a turnip. If a debtor can’t pay with money, he’ll pay with pain. Here torture’s purpose is to intimidate – to send a message to others who might be tempted renege on their debts. Does that remind you of Mafia leg-breakers?
Nonetheless, at the end of the parable, Matthew has Jesus saying: “So will my heavenly Father do to you unless each of you forgives your brothers from your heart.” Contradictions, anyone? Silliness? Intimidation?
In fact, Jesus could never have spoken these words because, as I said, they run counter to the instructions that precede them. They also contradict the descriptions of God exemplified in biblical teachings as found in today’s reading from Sirach, Psalms, Romans, and the Gospel of John.
Not only that. Jesus’ audience was filled with debtors whose lives were imiserated by Shylocks like the king in this morning’s story. They would never have listened to a teacher who identified God with such oppressors.
So what’s up with Matthew? Why does he insist on a punishing God who seems to support economic exploitation and Mafia ethics?
Fact is: right from the beginning it was difficult for Jesus’ followers (especially those like Matthew who never met him) to leave behind their religion’s overwhelming concept of a violent, punishing God. Moreover, despite Jesus’ teaching about the entirely new order represented by God’s Kingdom, they found it nearly impossible to distance themselves from the contradictory normality of economic exploitation, human trafficking, slavery, torture, war and violence.
So early on, all those elements crept back into Christianity – again, despite Jesus’ teaching and example. And those elements covered with a veneer of faith are precisely what is killing us today. Or, as Jack Nelson-Pallmeyer has put it: that’s why Religion is Killing Us:Violence in the Bible and Quran.
Christians have no trouble seeing that with Islam. But as Nelson-Pallmeyer has explained, it’s just as true of Christianity.
So, as I just said, Christianity like that presented in today’s gospel has been made to support everything Jesus stood against.
In the face of such contradictions, what are believers to do? My answer:
- Be discerning.
- Realize that Christianity is just as threatening to the world as we imagine religions like Islam to be.
- Accordingly, embrace atheism before violent, exploitative images of God like the Mafia Don Matthew presents.
- At the same time, embrace Jesus’ forgiving Father.
- After the usual sermon today, question your priest or minister about the king in this morning’s gospel.
- Most importantly, strive to act like that God as embodied in Jesus practice on the cross.
Seventy times seven is only the beginning!
4 thoughts on “(Sunday Homily) Matthew’s God as Mafia Don: The Religion That’s Killing Us”
Mike RS, this will seem maybe like a non-sequitur (although your writing above does talk about exploitation)
Berea classes have sometimes traveled to Oaxaca and Chiapas, and you have brought speakers from the region to Berea. I read the link below and wondered if you have heard from anyone down there in Chiapas, and if the towns where you visited are okay? It sounds very difficult. They are in my thoughts though I don’t know what could be done if aid is being blocked
Dear Mary, So good to hear from you. Sorry for the long delay in responding. I appreciate your reading the blog occasionally, and I have missed your dissenting and always thoughtful comments. The answer is that I really haven’t heard from friends in Oaxaca and Chiapas. Like you, though, I’ve been keeping them in my prayers. Thanks again
Thanks for this Mike.
I heard Pope Francis said last week that he couldn’t understand what was going on in Maduro’s head!
One thing I could guess might be going on is remembering Salvador Allende and how the right wing elitist groups in Chile consorted and plotted with the U.S. to wreck the economy and so undermine the Government effort.
Venezuela gets such poor reporting. It always reflects the anti-socialist bias of the U.S. and E.U. Like you, I’m surprised if Pope Francis, as a Latin American, doesn’t grasp the real situation there more firmly.